Wednesday, March 18, 2009

American Idol

I am writing this on Tuesday evening. I've just spent the last hour and a half priming the bathroom on the main level of the house for a new coat of paint. Last Monday Lisa ripped all of the wallpaper out of the bathroom. It needed to be ripped out. It was begging to be ripped out. It was maybe 40 years old and had an ugly, ugly pattern on it. This link is to a photograph of some wallpaper that is about as ugly. The wallpaper in the photo isn't exactly the same pattern as what was in our bathroom, but it's about the same on the Oh My God Scale. When we bought the house we knew that sooner or sooner we were going to take the wallpaper down.

Anyway, as I was working I heard Lisa downstairs watching American Idol and I thought, Hey, I want to watch American Idol rather than paint! Then I thought better of that statement. I've really gotten tired of that overblown talent competition. I've always hated the initial "tryout" episodes that alternate between talented individuals, people who THINK they're talented individuals, and people just looking to get on national TV for 15 seconds. I usually have skipped those shows and waited for "Hollywood" week.

This year, though, I've found even the talented singers a) not that talented and b) not that entertaining. And they don't seem to be growing, either. In past years it seems like there was always someone who got better and better each week, until after the second or third round it becomes obvious that this person is going to be the winner. Kelly Clarkson was pretty obvious in the first season, and when she sang "Respect" when there were still 30 people left I turned to Lisa and said, "There's your winner right there. We don't even need to watch the rest of the season." I also correctly chose Rueben Studdard and Fantasia very early on and watched them grow into winners.

In Season Four I wasn't so lucky. After going three for three in the first three seasons I told everyone I knew that I would pick the winner BEFORE the final 12 were chosen. I picked Constantine Maroulis, who ended up finishing sixth. He started strong but never really improved.

Maybe because of my wrong pick I didn't even watch the 5th or 6th seasons, but I watched again last year after the final 12 had been chosen, and during Beatles week (whenever that was) I chose David Cook to be the winner, and again I was right.

This year I said early on it would either be Danny Gokey or Lil Rounds, but I'm not so sure anymore. Lil has the best voice, I think, but I don't see her growing at all, and Danny is likable enough, but I think I'm just tired of the whole thing. Maybe I need to pick a new reality show to watch, something like Dancing with the Stars. I've only seen a few minutes of that show, but in that little bit of time I've seen two things it has going for it: 1) Attractive women dancing in skimpy outfits, and 2) the potential for somebody famous to fall and hurt themselves in an embarrassing manner.

Neither of those things ever happen on American Idol.

No comments: