Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Rand Paul is NOT "The Guy"

Before I had the job I have now, back when I was a high school English teacher, I did quite a bit of consulting in the field of writing instruction. I worked with every school in my district and with schools in several surrounding districts on ways to help teachers help students to become better writers. And in every situation, I found the faculty members at those schools to be cooperative. True, each school was different, with its own challenges and with its own unique culture, but in every case the faculty was willing to work to solve the problems it faced and to work in the best interest of the students.

Except at one school.

There was one school where I presented two sessions during two different school years. The first was a day long session where the school was hoping to revamp the entire way that it handled writing portfolios (which used to be a staple of state assessment in Kentucky), and the second was a shorter training about something--I honestly can't remember what.

It doesn't matter what the subjects of the trainings were, though. I left both trainings at this school (and you better believe that NOTHING could drag the name of this school out of me) utterly disgusted with how dysfunctional the teachers were. Not as individuals, but as a group. The problem was this: For whatever reason, the teachers were divided into three separate groups, consisting of a small group of older teachers who sat together at a round table in the back of the library, a small group of even older teachers who sat together at a round table in the FRONT of the library, and a larger group of teachers, mostly young teachers, who sat wherever they could find a seat. The Old Group (Let's call them Group 1) couldn't stand the Older Group (Group 2), and the feeling was reciprocated. As a result, no idea that came from anyone in Group 1 was going to be accepted by Group 2, and no idea that came from Group 2 was going to be accepted by Group 1. To make matters worse, there were a couple of teachers in Group 2 who were knee jerk pessimists anyway, and so regardless of where an idea on the floor came from--even from their own group--they would find a problem with it. And they were both loud and abrasive, and they usually got their way.

This meant that NOTHING got done. We spent an entire six hour day trying to revamp their writing portfolio process. But after six hours of work, including time working together by department and time working together by grade, we finally had a plan, only to have Group 1 stand up and belittle the elements of the plan that came from Group 2, and Group 2 to stand up and belittle the elements of the plan that came from Group 1, and for the two negative teachers to stand and belittle EVERYONE including me. In the end, the grand plan was never implemented.

When I went back the following year for the shorter training, I complained about the buzz saw that I knew I was about to walk into. And I wished--oh, how I wished--that things could be different. And I actually knew HOW to make things different. If I could just find a way to get those two groups out of the library, then the rest of the teachers and I could actually get something done.

And that's the way I feel about political extremists today, about what's happening in Washington and in Frankfort. Group 1 (the Democrats) and Group 2 (the Republicans) are so dead set on destroying the other group that they're getting NOTHING done, and Group 3 (you and I) are the ones that suffer as a result. You and I would LIKE to get something done, we see that there is some room for compromising and some areas of mutual agreement, we even see the way to move toward some real progress, but we're powerless to do anything because of the extremist legislators bent on proving the other party wrong.

The obvious thing to do, then, would be to vote the extremists out of Congress, move toward moderate Democrats and moderate Republicans who will work together to get things done. But that's not what's happening. If anything, we're moving in the opposite direction. The Republican Party in the state of Kentucky HAD a chance to nominate a moderate Republican to replace Jim Bunning--Trey Grayson is a good man, and by almost any definition, he's a staunch conservative, with your standard set of Republican values. But did Kentucky Republicans nominate him? No, they went with Rand Paul, a right-right-right wing conservative, who has a penchant so far for saying outrageous things that might whip the Republican base into a frenzy, but that isn't going to play well with Democrats and with moderate Republicans. I think he'll have a tough time getting elected in November.

But my fear isn't that he'll lose. My fear is that he'll WIN. That he'll go to Washington and become another extremist who'll help bog down the government and get nothing done.

So if you're a Kentuckian, even if you're a Kentuckian with conservative values, please think twice before voting for Paul. Let's not put another negative teacher in the library. I can't take it anymore!

No comments: