Friday, June 25, 2010

The War in Afghanistan

I may be sticking my finger into a hornet's nest with this post, but I feel like it absolutely needs to be said...

As I've been following the news about the ousting of General Stanley McChrystal from Afghanistan, I've heard several national news commentators state that part of the reason for the general's actions are that he knows that we are doomed to failure in Afghanistan and McChrystal wants out before the failure falls on him. Many have said that now is the time for us to go ahead and get out of Afghanistan.

I want to remind everyone, though, that we have a very real reason for being in Afghanistan. I've complained since the beginning that we have no business being in Iraq, but we're in Afghanistan BECAUSE THE TALIBAN ATTACKED US! This isn't a war of choice--this is a war to defend our country.

The fact that we had to go to Afghanistan makes me very sad. I remember in 2001 standing in front of one of my English classes and saying how profoundly sad I was that thousands of Afghani's were going to die because of what happened on September 11, and that maybe some of the young men and women in that classroom would die as well (though I can thankfully say that I don't THINK anyone I know has died on the battlefield in either Afghanistan OR Iraq). But I also said that we HAD to go over to Afghanistan--we HAD to. We'd been attacked and we had to respond.

Our task in Afghanistan isn't finished. We've set up a new government, but it's a corrupt government and it doesn't control even the majority of the country geographically. The Taliban--the people who attacked us on September 11--are still in control of much of the country.

If we leave now, the message we send is that you can attack the United States if you want and get away with it. Sure, the Americans will come over to your country and blow off some steam and kill a few thousand people, but if you hide in caves long enough they'll grow weary of the fighting and leave you alone.

That's a bad message to send. It's EXACTLY what Osama bin Laden and other members of Qaeda and the Taliban said about Americans before the attacks--that we were weak and couldn't stomach war. Leaving will just prove that they're right.

So let's change the guy in charge. McChrystal was disrespectful and deserves to be removed from command. But let's not forget why we're in Afghanistan, and let's not make the mistake of proving that bin Laden was right all those years ago.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Sometimes I really question is it really worth it, we just kill off our young guys and gals and get nowhere. I think this is a loser.