
I was corresponding recently with a friend from high school that I hadn't seen in years and I told her something that was the absolute truth: she hadn't changed at all. She looked exactly the same as she had when she was in high school. Her reply to that was something along the lines of, "Well, I didn't think I was anything special in high school, so that's not much of a compliment!"
The funny thing is, though, that she was a very attractive person in high school. And that got me thinking about what I think is an almost universal truism: Below a certain age (maybe 16, maybe 17), NOBODY thinks they're very good looking. I taught high school English for 14 years, and at my school, because English was the only class at the time that every student had to take, class pictures were taken and distributed through the English class, which meant that I got to see all of my students' class pictures. On average during those 14 years I saw 100 new students each year. That's approximately 1,400 individuals that I taught during my tenure. And I can tell you from experience that of those 1,400 students, 1,328 or so of them HATED their school pictures. Everyone thinks they're ugly.
I wish somebody had told me that when I was in high school. Actually, I think plenty of people told me that in high school. I wish I'd believed them. Maybe I would have had a little more confidence.
On the other hand, maybe I wouldn't have. Because the truth is that--more than most people--I really WASN'T very attractive when I was in school. And I know what you're thinking: He probably was just like everybody else he's describing, overly hard on himself. But that's not the case, and I've got the photo evidence to prove it.
Not in every class, but in at least one section every year when I was teaching, there would be one student who wasn't just upset by his or her class picture, but instead was devastated. I remember one girl actually being in tears and trying so hard to hide those tears from the class. I discreetly took her in the hall and asked her what was wrong.
"I'm so ugly!" she said simply.
"Oh, girl," I told her, "you don't know!" I then brought her back into the classroom and got out my secret weapon: my 8th grade yearbook, which I kept stashed on the shelf inside my podium for just this occasion.
"Class," I said, "I got to see everyone of your photos today, and some of you, I know, might not like your picture. In fact, you might be thinking that your photo is the worst class picture ever taken!" That girl and a few others nodded. "I'm here today to tell you that there is no way that your picture is the worst yearbook picture ever. I don't care how bad your picture is, there is no way that it can beat my 8th grade yearbook photo. It is absolutely the worst yearbook picture of all time!" I then would actually get out my 7th grade yearbook photo and pass it around so that they could see that in the year prior I actually looked halfway normal. Sure, I had a stupid grin on my face, and sure, I was wearing a shirt that had Steve Martin's "Well, Excuuuuuuse Me!" written on it, and sure, my hair was plastered down, parted, and combed across my head like I was a middle-aged man with a comb over, but I still looked about as normal as the rest of the kids on the page. And then I would hold that blue 8th grade yearbook up and tell them the dreaded story.
"During the summer between my 7th and 8th grade years," I'd say, "something terrible happened to me, something that took me YEARS to get over. My hair--I don't know how to explain it--my hair CHANGED! It went from being completely flat and completely straight to being sort of a white man's Afro. It became EXTREMELY kinky, like nothing I'd ever dealt with before, and I didn't know how to handle it. I didn't want curly hair. I wanted my straight hair back. And I tried to compensate by getting men's hair spray and spraying it on my hair, but my superpower hair was too much for it. I responded by using even more hairspray. I would comb my hair down while it was wet and would still lay down, and then I would spray it with about 1/4 can of hair spray, the end result being that I had a sort of plastic-like helmet of hair on my head. And all was good in life. Until...
"...until gym glass, which was early in the morning. I'd go to gym class and exercise and sweat, and all of that perspiration would melt that hair spray, and in the areas I hadn't sprayed as heavily as the others, my hair would curl up. Then after I'd cool down, the hair spray would sort of harden again, and I'd be stuck with my hair sort of randomly curly in some places and straight in others. It was really quite comical. Or sad. Depends on how you look at. I'd rather laugh than cry about it, so let's go with comical.
"That's how my hair looked on Picture Day in the 8th grade. My hair was straight all over except for three places. There was a giant ball of curl right on the top of my hair, a ball so large that it had sort of drooped over to one side by the weight of itself. I also had two little wisps of hair that had curled up--almost like horns--just above each of my ears! To top it off, my glasses didn't quite fit me right for whatever reason, so they were leaning to one side in classic nerd fashion! And I wasn't an idiot: I KNEW how ridiculous I looked, so I wasn't even smiling in the picture. I had this morose, depressed look on my face. I fully suspected that I was about to take part in the creation of the Worst Yearbook Picture Ever!"
I then passed my 8th grade yearbook picture around for everyone to see. The reaction was always the same: Each person would look at the yearbook with this look of skepticism, sure I'd blown the ugliness of the photo way out of proportion. But they were never prepared for the truth: the picture was so bad that my words didn't do it justice. I would watch the eyes of every person, and each person would scan through the photos of normal kids until my face was found, and then that person's eyes would open wide and he or she would start laughing hysterically. It continued that way all around the room, with the people who saw it first turning to the people at the other end of the room and saying, "He's not lying!" You would think that the effect would diminish as the yearbook made its way around the room, that by the time it got to the last students that the expectations would be ratcheted up so high that there was no way that the real photo could exceed those expectations. But it always did.
The year the student was crying I paid special attention to her. She saw the picture and laughed just like everyone else. After she handed the yearbook to the person behind her she turned and looked at me and smiled. I smiled back and for just a moment remembered what I loved about teaching. And then I turned from her and faced the throng of people waiting to make fun of me.
"You're a geek!" someone shouted out.
"Tell me something I don't know," I'd say flatly in return.
I remember one popular girl looking at me like she was seeing me with new eyes. "Mr. Sweasy," she said, "you really were a giant dork, weren't you?"
"Yeah," I said. "I really was."
1,400 students. Not one of them ever disagreed with me that I had the worst yearbook picture ever. One girl one year, though, stayed after class one day and brought me a picture from two years before. "Yours is still the worst," she told me, "but this one comes close, doesn't it?"
I couldn't argue with her. I nodded and said, "It's really close."
She laughed. "But I don't look like that anymore. I don't look good, but I don't look like that anymore. And you survived, Mr. Sweasy, and that means that I'm going to survive, too, doesn't it?"
"Yeah," I said. "It does."
This is a long entry. I guess I just wanted to say this to my old friend: Everyone thinks he or she is "nothing special" in high school. But you WERE something special then, and you are now, too. The compliments are sincere.