
I wanted to talk really quickly about
the whole hubbub regarding Henry Louis Gates, Jr.'s arrest, and tell a quick story about a similar situation that happened to me...
If you don't know the story, Gates, a prominent Harvard professor, came home one night to find his front door broken. He basically had to "break into" his house in order to get in. A neighbor saw him wrestling with his front door and thought it was a REAL break in, so the police were called. The police came and, despite Gates having a driver's license that showed he lived at this address, he was arrested.
Gates, who is African-American, claims that he was treated this way because of race, and there certainly may be some merit to his claim. However, I can't help but feel that we don't have the whole story here. The police officer insists that Gates was arrested because he became belligerent and offensive to the police. While I don't think the police are completely innocent in this matter, I can't believe that Gates is completely innocent either.
And as I said, I have a story to tell. A very similar story, actually...
I don't remember the exact year, but I know that it was sometime between 2000 and 2004. I know this because my family and I were living at Vent Haven Museum, but I was still teaching. Everyone else in my family had gone to sleep, but I was awake grading writing portfolios (which is pretty much how I spent most of August-March for about six years). I took a break from grading and decided that--before I forgot--I had better set the museum alarm system for the night. The system protects the four museum buildings AND the curator's home where we lived. When I punched the key code into the system the system acted like it was arming, but instead of beeping 5 beeps over and over for about 30 seconds, it instead let out one long beep followed by a pause and then another long beep. I thought it weird, but I just reset the system to normal and then re-enabled the alarm, and everything seemed fine.
What I didn't know at the time (but learned just a few minutes later) was that the alarm system had a "panic" setting on it. If a person was under duress and was being forced to turn off or on the alarm, the panic setting could be used. It mimicked the resetting of the alarm, but it also silently notified the police.
Usually when the alarm goes off, before the police ever arrive, the alarm company would call to make sure that this was an actual alarm and not a false alarm. But they don't do that with a panic alarm because they don't want to tip off the intruder that the police are on their way. So I didn't get a warning call. I was just sitting at our kitchen table in sweats and a t-shirt, drinking decaffeinated coffee and grading an essay, when the doorbell rang. I jumped up, afraid the doorbell would awaken Lisa or one of my kids, who were just little toddlers back then. When I got to the door I saw that it was a police officer. I ran back, disabled the alarm, and opened the door.
"Can I help you, officer?" I asked him.
"There was an alarm drop from this location," the officer told me seriously, looking me up and down.
"Really?" I asked as I stepped outside. "We didn't get a call from the alarm company like we usually do."
"It was a panic alarm," the police officer told me, and he then explained to me pretty much what I'd just told you above about a panic alarm. He then said, "It's used when someone is in distress."
"Well," I said, trying to be funny, "I'm having a little distress about these essays that I'm grading, but everyone else in my house is asleep. I don't think they're in distress at all."
The police officer laughed heartily for several seconds and then paused and said very seriously, "Do you mind if I come inside, and would you mind showing me some ID?"
Now, if I'd been a black man, like Gates, I might have assumed that the police officer wanted to come inside because I was black. And I guess, to some extent, I WAS a little offended by the questions because I understood what the questions meant: this officer didn't entirely trust me that everything was okay. I could have gotten angry. I could have gotten belligerent and refused to help. I could have gotten myself arrested, like Gates did.
But I didn't. A little voice inside of me told me that the police officer was only doing his job, and so, though I'm pretty sure that I looked and sounded NOTHING like a criminal, I let the police officer come in and I showed him my ID, which showed that I lived at the house. I offered him some of my coffee; he declined but did ask if I had some water. I got him a bottle of water out of the refrigerator and he and I stood in the entry to the house and talked for a few minutes. I asked him to talk in a low voice because everyone was asleep and he did so. After a few minutes he said he was satisfied that it was a false alarm, and he left.
My point in all of this? I don't think Gates was treated the way he was initially because he was a black man. I think he was treated the way he was because the person across the street reported a break in at his house, and the police were treating anyone in the house as a potential criminal (There's another question of whether racism was involved in why the person across the street made the call in the first place, but that's a discussion for another day). His later treatment MAY have been a result of racial profiling or it MAY simply have been a result of his belligerent attitude. And I think President Obama needed to wait for all of the facts to come out before making his judgment. I'm going to wait, anyway.