Thursday, October 15, 2009

On Knives and Suspensions

I'm sure most people now have heard the story of the six year old boy who brought a camping knife to school and was promptly suspended by his district's board of education for 45 days. Earlier this week that board of education, under pressure from mounting complaints and massive media coverage showing a bright faced little boy in cute Sunday-best suits, relented and let the boy back into school.

Before I get to my real comment about all of this, let me make one thing clear: I agree that the board of education acted stupidly. Zero tolerance policies are a BAD idea. Always. There isn't a single crime I can think of where a zero tolerance policy would work. Not even rape and murder. In Nazi concentration camps prisoners were forced by prison guards to rape and murder one another, and no one would ever have suggested that those prisoners should have been prosecuted for those crimes. Zero tolerance policies are politically popular policies because they sound tough and because--like Pontious Pilate--they allow those in authority to "wash their hands" of any punishment and to avoid making any tough decisions. "Don't blame us," they say. "It's out of our hands. It's just policy."

The Newark board of education absolutely was wrong. They should have taken into account that the boy was six years old, that the camping utensil was hardly a weapon, that the old-style mathematical compass that was used when we were kids was more dangerous. I'm not sure the child deserved ANY punishment, and definitely not a 45 day suspension.

But the overwhelming thing I got out of this story was not outrage. Instead, as I watched and read all of the media coverage about the story, I was left with a question: How would this whole story have played out if the young boy had been black? What if, instead of the child being that fresh-faced white child in a suit, the child was a black child, dressed in blue jeans and a dirty t-shirt, and instead of all of those interviews taking place in a nice house in the suburbs, what if those interviews were given from the kitchen of a lower-income housing project? Would all of the outrage still be there? And if there was outrage, would it still be directed at the school board, or would it instead be directed at the parents? "That's what they get," I can imagine some commentators saying, "for allowing that boy to play with a weapon. It's just like them. And it's what's wrong with society today!"

I don't know. I'd like to think that the reaction would be the same regardless of the race of the child, that the public outrage would be the same regardless of the income level of the family or how the child looked. I'd like to think we've progressed beyond all of that.

I'd LIKE to think so...

1 comment:

Building The Willys said...

Actually lets see long it would have taken Rev Al or Jesse Jackson to decrey that it was racial and that the black kid was treated that way BECAUSE he was black. In all probability there would have been marches. "We will overcome" chants and in general a national "Black" outcry. Just look at what happened to Rush and the football team buy. He is quoted as saying things he says he never said but because he is honest in his OPINION he is just another racist. We are in the age of "Personal Destrction" led by a White House that makes Nixon's plumbers appear to be amatuer at best. In closing I ask the simple question: If Obama is Bi-racial then why are blacks that say something about him not called racists. You cannot be a racist UNLESS you are white!